Fitbit, Garmin, Jawbone: The 'Before You Buy' Guide For Fitness Trackers

Leonardo da Vinci called simplicity “the ultimate sophistication," and in that regard, fitness trackers are truly refined. Fitness trackers are now as ubiquitous at the gym as a pair of white earbuds. Their popularity is a testament to the draw of technology that works well without breaking the bank.

Manufacturers like Fitbit, Garmin, and Jawbone have offered connected exercise products for years, appealing to consumers who want simple functionality at a lower price. While smartwatches offer a more robust set of features, fitness band manufacturers have stuck to the basics, tracking a user's sleep and activity. Yet even within that range, pricing is variable, with fitness tracking wearables ranging from under $20 to well over $1,500. How to select the one that's right for you? Let's begin.

Fitbit Charge 6 Fitness Tracker with Heart Rate, GPS, Premium Membership, and Health Tools - Gold Case w/ Red Band, 1.04 Screen

Fitbit Charge 6 Fitness Tracker with Heart Rate, GPS, Premium Membership, and Health Tools - Gold Case w/ Red Band, 1.04 Screen

List Price: $159.95

New From: $148.20in Stock

Used From: $138.00in Stock

What Features Do You Want?

The best way to determine which fitness tracker fits you best is to decide which features you need. Activity tracking may come in all models, but not all devices look or even wear the same. Some will have features you may crave, and some you may find unnecessary.

Heart rate monitors can be a big plus for users looking to maximize their workouts and track progress. Certain models will only calculate your heart rate while working out — but won't read your resting heart rate. Other fitness bands, like those offered by Garmin, opt out of a built-in heart rate monitor altogether to lower costs and improve battery life, but then offer a compatible chest strap for workouts that can be purchased separately.

Most fitness trackers will include some form of sleep tracking. This varies from recording the number of hours you sleep each night to determining the quality of your sleep based on your movements. Some models, like the Jawbone UP2 ($99) and the Jawbone UP3 ($179), can even tell when you've entered REM sleep based on factors such as your heart rate or body temperature. These can help trigger “smart wake" features, from simple vibrations or to sound-based alerts that attempt to wake the user before or after they enter an REM cycle.

UP3 by Jawbone Heart Rate, Activity + Sleep Tracker, Indigo Twist (Navy Blue)

UP3 by Jawbone Heart Rate, Activity + Sleep Tracker, Indigo Twist (Navy Blue)

Screen Or No Screen?

Digital displays are absent from many lower-priced fitness bands, like the Jawbone UP series and devices from Misfit and Xiaomi. One drawback of not having a screen is that you can't see how many steps you've taken without checking your smartphone, nor can you quickly see the time. Displays are also useful for checking the time and providing other information.

As you increase in price, fitness devices offer more add-ons, including heart rate monitors, GPS, sleep tracking, and even reminders to get moving. Heart rate monitoring is a particularly helpful feature, ensuring you're pushing yourself hard enough during a workout but not overdoing it. Users with heart health issues or athletes looking to maximize their aerobic fitness also lean towards this feature, found in several devices, including the Fitbit Charge HR, Apple Watch, and several Garmin Forerunner models.

Recovery is just as key to fitness as a workout, and several trackers now record a user's sleep pattern and cycles by sensing movement during the night. Devices like the Misfit Shine can detect the difference between light and heavy sleep based on motion. Others can calculate REM cycles using your heart rate (Fitbit Charge HR), your skin temperature (Jawbone UP3) or both (Basis Peak).

What Activity Will You Primarily Be Tracking?

Whether you are training for your first marathon or jogging to lose weight, there are a number of features to look for in a fitness tracker. For runners, basic features to consider are the ability to show time and lap times, the distance you have run and also your pace.

Built-in GPS makes tracking much more accurate, and is recommended for serious runners. It's available in select tracking watches, like most Garmin models, including the Forerunner 25 ($169). The Fitbit Surge ($249) and the Polar M400 ($229 MSRP, available lower at certain retailers) also have models with built-in GPS.

Swimmers have particular needs, and no trackers are made equal regarding being waterproof. Many are merely water-resistant and not recommended for use in the pool. The Garmin Vivoactive ($249) or the Misfit Shine ($69) for a budget option. Those willing to shell out an extra $10 can gain more swim-focused activity features in the Misfit Speedo Shine ($79).

Those on two wheels also have to decide whether they want to merely track their distance and calories burned or their cadence—the number of revolutions they turn every minute. Models that support additional bicycle-mounted sensors include the Mio Fuse ($149).

Garmin Vivoactive Black

List Price: $249.99

New From: $181.75in Stock

Used From: $135.00in Stock

What Form Factor Fits You?

Now that you've narrowed down what you want from a device consider how you'd like it to look. There are three main categories for fitness trackers: dongles, wristbands, and watches. Dongles are generally less expensive and more basic, whereas watches have more features and a higher price tag. Wristbands fall somewhere in the middle.

Dongle trackers often clip onto clothing or into a wristband. Thanks to their small size, they can also be worn on your shirt, bra or along the arm. Most models do not have displays, so dongles like the Jawbone UP Move and Misfit Flash rely on a smartphone or computer to track your workout.

Watch-type trackers are more customizable by size, sometimes have locking wristbands, and occasionally have a larger, round display. If you're not used to wearing a standard wristwatch anymore, it may take some time to get used to it again.

What Apps and Services are right for you?

What do you plan to do with the data your fitness tracker gathers? To make sense of your steps, sleep or heart rate, the service that comes with your device will likely play a major role in your decision.

Fitbit offers apps and websites that are highly rated by customers. Unlike its competitors, Fitbit's services can record data not collected by its wearables, including stress, food tracking, and blood pressure. Garmin recently released the ConnectIQ platform, which allows runners, cyclists, and swimmers to download third-party applications and also customize its watch faces.

If you plan on purchasing a full-featured smartwatch, many activity-tracking features are also included. The Apple Watch ($349 and up) incorporates Apple's Healthkit software suite, which ties together health information collected from the Watch and the iPhone. Google also offers Android Wear, a suite of devices from differing manufacturers that connects to its health app, Android Fit, which tracks steps while using an Android smartphone. But other brands, like Withings, also offer separate apps that don't require you to buy its classy, analog smartwatch.

The right choice is the option that best suits your fitness and health needs—and perhaps also your wallet.

- YouTubeWant to know how to select the right fitness tracker? GearBrain provides you with a buying guide for fitness trackers. it's a quick ...